Stepsisters Avi Love and Paisley Bennett haven't seen their family friend, Seth Gamble, in years. Growing up, Seth was so close to the girls that they referred to him as their cousin. Now, he's just smoking hot and the girls can't stop flirting. Serene Siren and Brock Doom tell their daughters to go set the table for Thanksgiving while they finish up cooking dinner. Paisley goes ahead, but Avi tugs Seth along with them. With a little bit of privacy, the girls have time to flash their tits and asses at Seth as they continue to flirt with him. They're both a bit competitive, but they manage to not get caught by their parents.
Once they're seated at the table, the girls continue to compete for Seth's attention. They get sexual with the way they suck their silverware. When that doesn't work, Paisley reaches over and pops Seth's hard dick from his pants to start stroking him off. Avi isn't about to be outdone. She puts her hand over Paisley's so they're delivering a double handie. Standing up and lifting her miniskirt, Avi ups the ante by sliding down on Seth's dick right at the dinner table. Serene calls Avi out and she gets off of him reluctantly. They manage to wait until Serene and Brock declare that they're full and clear the plates from the table.
Now it's time for dessert! The girls work together to suck Seth off. Then Avi peels off her skirt and pulls her panties aside so Seth can lean her over the table and fuck her as Paisley sucks his balls. Paisley's patience is rewarded as Avi helps her onto the table so Seth can slam into her and deliver a ball slapping delight. Turning over, Paisley continues to take it from behind as Avi joins her on the table so Paisley can eat her stepsister out. Then Paisley gets up and Avi scoots forward so Seth can bang her while Paisley rides her face. Seth can't wait another moment to cum; he gluts Avi with a Thanskgiving creampie that Paisley eagerly runs her fingers through as it drips out of her sister's trimmed snatch. They're nearly caught as Brock yells for them to bring the dishes, but they scurry to find their clothes.