Dressed in matching outfits, Maria Anjel and Scarlett Hampton are in the process of decorating for a St. Patty's party when Scarlett's stepbrother, Jay Romero, walks in on them. He asks about their shirts, which say Ask Me, I Might… Scarlett tells him that they might show off their cute tits with their shamrock pasties. Before they will let Jay see the goods, though, Maria and Scarlett want to convince Jay that he needs to act on Scarlett's stepfamily sex fetish.

Turning around, the girls shake their booties to sweeten Jay up and then tell him that he has to put his dick through something and let his mom catch him. The family fetish involves getting caught. Jay says no, but later they find him with his hardon in a bowl of cereal. They call Jay's mom and let her catch them with Scarlett's hand on Jay's cock. She storms off to get Scarlett's dad and Scarlett tells Jay he'd better fuck her fast.

The girls begin their reward for Jay's cooperation with a double blowjob. Then Scarlett finally get to live out her family sex fetish as Jay fucks her in doggy while she rubs down her BFF's snatch. Maria gets a go at the D when she scoots forward on her back and takes him between her thighs. Cradled in Scarlett's arms, she really lets herself enjoy. She keeps her bon temps rolling as she rides Jay's fuck stick in cowgirl. Scarlett gets on her back for Jay to do her one last time and then squeals in delight as he pulls out to cover her in his cum. Just as the girls are snowballing their treat, Scarlett and Jay's parents return home.